Creamy Pumpkin Egg Custard: My Coziest Homemade Recipe
Just Between Friends: How I Fell for Creamy Pumpkin Egg Custard
Alright, so let me paint you a picture: it was a drizzly Saturday in October, my socks were slightly damp from stepping in something questionable by the back step, and I’d just come in form the market with a pumpkin that was, no exaggeration, roughly the size of a small dog. What was I going to do, make soup again? Nope—this time I decided to finally try my grandma’s old creamy pumpkin egg custard. She used to swear her version was better than Mrs. Finch’s (nobody liked Mrs. Finch’s, for the record), and after many wobbly, slightly overbaked attempts, I reckon I finally got it right—well, mostly right. There’s something about whisking together eggs and pumpkin, then watching it puff and set into this golden, smooth custard… okay, I’m getting carried away. But seriously, this is comfort food at its finest, and it wanders somewhere between a dessert and a sneaky breakfast if you’re not careful.
Why You’ll Love This (or at Least Not Regret Making It)
I make this when the air smells like leaf piles and I’ve got some canned pumpkin to use up. My family goes absolutely bonkers for it, which is funny because they all used to claim they didn’t even like custard (kids, right?). Also, it’s the perfect dessert if you want something cozy but really don’t want to fuss with pie crusts that stick or crack—honestly, pastry is my kitchen nemesis. Plus, it’s not too sweet, and I swear something magical happens when pumpkin mingles with warm spices and creamy eggs (I mean, how could it not?). Oh, and if you overbake it a little, it’s still tasty—just call it ‘extra set’ and nobody complains.
Here’s What You’ll Need
- 1 1/2 cups pumpkin puree (I use canned when I’m lazy, but fresh is fine if you’re ambitious. Trader Joe’s brand seems less watery to me.)
- 3/4 cup granulated sugar (Brown sugar works too – gives a little more depth. I even tried maple syrup once when I ran out but, eh, stick with sugar.)
- 3 large eggs
- 1 cup heavy cream (Light cream will work, and even full-fat milk in a pinch – but it’s best with cream honestly. Don’t do skim. Just… don’t.)
- 1/2 cup milk (Again, whatever is in the fridge. Whole milk is my go-to. Almond milk works if you’re in a dairy mess.)
- 1 teaspoon vanilla extract (My grandmother always insisted on using the real deal, but I have used the cheap stuff and survived.)
- 1/2 teaspoon ground cinnamon
- 1/4 teaspoon ground nutmeg
- 1/4 teaspoon salt
- Optional: pinch of ground ginger or clove (If you’re feeling wild. Sometimes I add a splash of bourbon, which is definitely not family tradition, but makes adults happy.)
Alright, Step-by-Step—But a Little Loosely, Just Like I Do
- First things first, put the kettle on (for tea or just company while you bake). Preheat your oven to 325°F (or 160°C). Set out a deep-ish baking dish, like an 8-inch square or anything that’ll fit about 6 ramekins snug. If you only have coffee mugs, those work too—I’ve done it in a pinch.
- Get a big mixing bowl. Toss in your pumpkin puree, sugar, eggs, cream, milk, vanilla, cinnamon, nutmeg, salt, and any bonus spices or a cheeky shot of bourbon. I usually whisk it until it’s all silky without any pockets of egg white. This is one of those stages where I can’t resist tasting—so sue me. Does it taste sweet enough? If not, a bit more sugar can’t hurt.
- Now pour it into your ramekins (or mugs or just one big dish—I don’t judge). Put them in the baking dish, then fill the dish with hot water till it comes about halfway up the sides. This is called a bain-marie, and yes, it matters. But, actually, I’ve skipped it once when I was in a hurry and lived to tell the tale. (The top did get a bit rubbery; lesson learned.)
- Bake for about 35–45 minutes for small dishes—up to 50 for one big dish. It should look set—barely jiggly in the center, like wobbling jelly. Don’t fuss if it’s still looking a bit quivery; it’ll firm up as it cools. But if it’s sloshing like soup, give it more time.
- Remove from the oven, carefully fish out your custards (I use tongs and a prayer). Let them cool, ideally on a rack if you have one. Then chill them in the fridge for at least an hour—or just eat it warm, spooned straight from the dish. No judgement here.
What I Learned the Awkward Way (Notes)
- Too much water in the bain-marie and the custards float. Oops—good news, the flavor still rocks.
- If you use fresh pumpkin, strain it through cheesecloth if it’s watery—that’s a trick I figured out after one truly soupy batch. Didn’t stop me from eating it, though.
- Actually, I’ve learned that it’s best to let them hang out in the fridge overnight (if you can wait), because the texture seems to get silkier. Or maybe it’s just me.
Variations I’ve Tried (Good and Not-so-good!)
- I swapped half the cream for coconut milk once—it gave it a tropical twist, which strangely works. My mother-in-law, on the other hand, was not a fan (she’s vocal like that).
- Adding orange zest seemed genius, but honestly, it was a bit odd. Not my best idea. Maybe stick to vanilla and cinnamon.
- You could use butternut squash if that’s what you have. I’ve done it, and it’s a bit lighter in flavor, but still tasty!
Equipment: You Don’t Need Anything Fancy
Sure, ramekins look cute and all, but you can use old coffee cups or a glass pie dish. If you haven’t got a deep baking pan for the water bath, I once used a roasting pan and propped up the custard dishes with crumpled foil as bumpers. Does the job.
Storing Leftovers (If You Even Get That Far)
Keep these covered in the fridge. Supposedly they’ll last about three days, but honestly, in my house it never lasts more than a day! If you sneak a spoonful in the night, I won’t judge—I’m usually right there with you.
How I Love to Serve This
We love it cold with a dollop of whipped cream and (just between us) a dusting of cocoa powder. Every Thanksgiving, I let the kids top theirs with crushed ginger snaps, which is now a tradition. It’s also great as breakfast with some oatmeal and a drizzle of honey (pumpkin for breakfast, why not?).
If I Could Do It Over—Pro Tips
- I once tried to rush the baking (impatient, what can I say?) and cranked the oven to 350. Regretted it big time because the custard got weirdly lumpy. Low and slow is the name of the game.
- Letting the custard cool before chilling really helps avoid that watery layer on the bottom. Took me a few times to figure that out. You’re welcome!
Real Questions (and Real Answers, Because People Ask…)
- Can I make this ahead?
Absolutely. In fact, I tend to think it tastes even better the next day—though once my cousin devoured half a pan while it was still warm. So, up to you. - Do I have to use a water bath?
If you want super smooth custard, yes, but I’ve accidentally skipped it, and while it wasn’t perfect, it wasn’t inedible either! - Can I freeze it?
Eh, it’s not great after thawing (it separates), but maybe that’s just me. I usually don’t have enough left to bother anyway. - Is it gluten-free?
It is as long as you don’t add any weird ingredients. I mean, check your vanilla and pumpkin purée just in case, but generally yes! - Where did you get your ceramic ramekins?
Would you believe I got mine on sale at Target? I’ve also seen cute sets at Crate & Barrel though.
Okay, this was almost as rambly as my usual kitchen adventures. Let me know if you try it—or if you discover a twist that blows my mind. (Bonus points if it doesn’t involve orange zest, ha.)
Ingredients
- 1 cup pumpkin puree
- 3 large eggs
- 3/4 cup heavy cream
- 1/3 cup granulated sugar
- 1/2 teaspoon ground cinnamon
- 1/4 teaspoon ground nutmeg
- 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
- 1/8 teaspoon salt
Instructions
-
1Preheat oven to 325°F (165°C). Place 4 ramekins in a baking dish.
-
2In a mixing bowl, whisk together pumpkin puree, eggs, sugar, cinnamon, nutmeg, vanilla extract, and salt until smooth.
-
3Gradually whisk in the heavy cream until fully combined and mixture is silky.
-
4Pour the custard mixture evenly into the ramekins.
-
5Pour hot water into the baking dish to come halfway up the sides of the ramekins. Carefully transfer to the oven.
-
6Bake for 35-40 minutes, or until custards are set but still slightly wobbly in the center. Cool, then chill before serving.
Approximate Information for One Serving
Nutrition Disclaimers
Number of total servings shown is approximate. Actual number of servings will depend on your preferred portion sizes.
Nutritional values shown are general guidelines and reflect information for 1 serving using the ingredients listed, not including any optional ingredients. Actual macros may vary slightly depending on specific brands and types of ingredients used.
To determine the weight of one serving, prepare the recipe as instructed. Weigh the finished recipe, then divide the weight of the finished recipe (not including the weight of the container the food is in) by the desired number of servings. Result will be the weight of one serving.
Did you make this recipe?
Please consider Pinning it!!
