Hey There, Sweet Tooth Friend!
You know, every Easter I find myself reminiscing about those childhood days of hunting for eggs in the yard and then, inevitably, the candy coma that followed. Now, instead of sneaking chocolates form the kids’ baskets, I’ve concocted these Vanilla Bean Easter Egg Popsicles—let me tell you, they’re a hit. The first time I made them, I accidentally used salt instead of sugar (oops!), but since then I’ve got it down to an art, well…sort of!
Why You’ll Love This
Honestly, I whip these up when I’m feeling extra festive (and maybe a tad nostalgic). My family goes crazy for these popsicles because they’re creamy and have that dreamy vanilla bean flavor. Plus, they look like little Fabergé eggs, which is a bonus! I must admit, the decorating part was a bit of a mess at first, but now I embrace the chaos—it’s more fun that way!
Gathering the Goods
- 2 cups of whole milk (or whatever you’ve got, really)
- 1/2 cup heavy cream (Greek yogurt works too, in a pinch)
- 1 vanilla bean (My grandma swore by vanilla extract; either works!)
- 1/2 cup sugar (or just a scant half cup if you prefer less sweet)
- Food coloring (optional, but it makes them pop!)
- Popsicle molds (or use Dixie cups and sticks if you’re like me and always misplace the molds)

The Fun Part: Making It
Alright, let’s jump in! First, slice that vanilla bean lengthwise and scrape out the seeds. Chuck them into a saucepan with the milk, cream, and sugar. Heat this gently until the sugar’s dissolved, stirring like it’s your second job. Mind you, don’t let it boil—just warm and cozy.
Now, let this mixture cool a bit. (This is where I usually sneak a taste!) Pour it into popsicle molds and add a drop or two of food coloring if you’re feeling adventurous. Freeze for at least 4 hours—though, on second thought, I’d say overnight for the best texture.
Notes from My Kitchen
So, I discovered by accident (thanks, toddler distraction) that letting the mixture sit a bit before freezing enhances the flavor. Who knew? Also, if you overfill the molds, don’t sweat it—I’ve done it a dozen times.

Mixing It Up
One time, I tried adding chocolate chips—bad idea. They sank like stones! But a swirl of raspberry puree was delightful. And, if you’re into a boozy twist, a splash of rum never hurt anyone, right?
Gear Up (or Not)
If you don’t have popsicle molds, who cares? Use paper cups and call it rustic chic. Sticks can be replaced with those fancy drink stirrers you never use.

Keeping Them Fresh
Store these in the freezer in an airtight container. Though, honestly, in my house, they never last more than a day because everyone devours them!
Serving It Up
I usually serve these at our Easter brunch alongside a fruit salad. My kids like to pretend they’re sharing with the Easter Bunny—adorable, right?
Lessons Learned
Once, I foolishly skipped cooling the mixture and ended up with icy blobs. So, don’t rush it—trust me, patience is key here!
FAQ Time!
Do these melt fast? Yes, they do—so eat them quick! Or just embrace the drips, like we do.
Can I use almond milk? Sure thing, but it changes the texture a bit. Give it a whirl!
What’s the best way to remove them from molds? Run them under warm water briefly—it’s like magic.